Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 8, 1977
Barton Hall - Cornell University
When I vote for a song, I'm not necessarily saying I think it's the best ever. Even if I do think this version is the best ever (and it might be), I don't like being told by someone who doesn't share that view that I think so because of X. You really have no idea. + When I first heard this tape in the mid-80s, it was not famous (at least that I knew of). I had already fallen for May 1977 based on a decent SBD of 5/19 a friend of mind had. When I heard this Scarlet>Fire, I recall being blown away by the little details (Weir throwing in a China Cat lick into Fire, for instance) and I still think this version contains everything one could want from the pairing. If the seamless transition is "boring" to some, OK. To me, it's hypnotic. Best ever? No clue here - there are certainly other Spring 77s that give this a run, but this is the one that opened me up to the possibilities of the pairing. + I don't think many (if any) post Spring 77 Scarlet>Fires touch this or the other ones played in April-May 1977. To my ears & taste, these are as close to perfect as I know. After this period (in general), the drums became flubbier, Garcia kept omitting/forgetting the 4th verse, Lesh's bass became muddier and less insistent, and some overall sloppiness often crept in. None of these issues touch Spring 77 for the most part. For my $.
