Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 8, 1977
Barton Hall - Cornell University
Jaivo-- I always welcome and encourage dissenting opinions but don't you think its a bit pretentious to dismiss and cast aside the opinions of so many others like that? Kind of arrogant to blanketly attribute people's love for this version to the "good sound quality" and the amount of time that it's been in circulation as if you somehow know the quote unquote "real reason" people like 5/8. This version holds legendary status for a lot more than just "good sound quality." I've heard many S>Fs, and many that people like to champion above 5/8, and I still don't believe it to be overrated. 5/8 isn't my favorite but I would never tell someone whose favorite is 5/8 that they only think so because "it's all they had" or because "the sound quality is good." Music is subjective, it's no secret. This one holds its weight to me and I wasn't even born until several years after JG passed-- you're telling me I only like this version because of nostalgia or the good sound quality? I'd beg to differ. Watch the vid ds67 linked. It's great and hopefully you can reconsider.