Terrapin Station
May 17, 1977
Memorial Coliseum
^^^^ Heady_V...
What you say here about Cornell is all true, and undoubtedly some Heads like to appear too cool for school by dissing it. In terms of introducing someone to the Dead for the first time there are some versions from Cornell I would not hesitate to use, starting with the Scarlet>Fire for an example of how very in the pocket they (and especially Phil) could be.
That said, there are legitimate gripes to be made about Cornell in regards to "best ofs" (which this site is chiefly about) that should not be dismissed as Heads being purposefully contrarian. What drives me a little batty is, for example, the uber high rankings for a song like "Brown Eyed Women" from Cornell, which, objectively speaking, can ONLY be because the version has 5/8/77 in front of it and people are just clicking it to the front because of that date. I refuse to let that go unchallenged. As I said on that entry page, it's a fine version. There's nothing wrong with it. But there's nothing that stands out about it, either, and there ARE so many others that objectively have more punch, are better sung, contain better jamming by Jerry, and are simply put, better. And yet there it is as #1 just because it has the mythical Cornell attached to it. That's what I object to--I am happy to have the "best
" Scar>Fire argument in relation to Cornell, best "Morning dew", etc., because ultimately even tho' I don't think the Cornell versions are THE best I would never denigrate anyone who thinks so because they are so undeniably good, so elite and upper echelon, that it makes perfect sense to have them in that discussion.
But there are a lot of other versions that get the "Cornell bump" that do not deserve it, and it overshadows many other better versions that people may not seek out, thinking that because of the high ranking and votes for 5/8/77, those lower ladder versions couldn't possibly be better than Cornell. But many of them are.