headyversion

find the best versions of grateful dead songs

please login or register.

grendel

Books and Music

+23524


Submissions

13
The Other One
May 18, 1977
Fox Theatre

Not sure why everyone ignores '77 versions, but you're missing out if you haven't heard this one. Power packed Jerry-led fury.
4
Spanish Jam
May 21, 1995
Sam Boyd Silver Bowl

In the band's worst year they somehow came up with a really short but spot-on SJ that emerges nicely out of space. Ignore the date-check out the tune.
4
It Must Have Been The Roses
March 13, 1981
Utica Coliseum

Seek out the SBD (unknown lineage) then bask in what's possibly the best-sung, most heartfelt & lovely "Roses" ever.
52
Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 11, 1977
St. Paul Civic Center Arena

It's criminal that this hasn't made the list yet. Like super-smooth '77 versions? You MUST hear this.
13
Gloria
Oct. 16, 1981
Melkweg

Bobby's birthday at the world famous Melkeweg. Yummy brownies make this version extra special.
show more submissions

Comments

Cold Rain and Snow
Feb. 3, 1978
Dane County Coliseum

^^^^Agree. Like Cornell & Veneta this (to be clear excellent top shelf show) gets bumps for songs that are fine but not extraordinary just b/c they're attached to a larger than life show. It's a disservice to both show & song. There are scads of versions way better than this one far lower on the list. (Just off the top of my head 8/25/72 leaps to mind). Great show--misleading ranking for this particular song in the pantheon of great CR&S
Playin' In The Band
Oct. 9, 1972
Winterland Arena

Gargantuan kitchen sink version with something for everyone. Aggressive in sections, quiet and contemplative in others, with a firm rhythm from Weir, Jerry’s usual runs of brilliance and my stars, if this isn’t one if the greatest performances by drummer Billy I don’t know what is. He takes control from the get go and rides the wave right up until...well, by now you should have read up on the hideous cut before the rejoin but honest to goodness it doesn’t take away from the overall magnificence of the journey. (One of the two archive versions has a noble fade out that’s at least better than an abrupt out)
The Other One
June 22, 1992
Star Lake Amphitheater

This deserves an upvote if for no other reason than the sheer originality of the approach. Hearing Bob begin the lyrics straight out of Spanish Jam AND IN THE MELODY OF SPANISH JAM!!! is at least to my knowing the only time they ever entered the song this way & it's a brilliant example of the experimentation and risk they were still willing to take even in the waning years. Whether it "works" or not is a matter of taste (I think it's grand) but I love the boldness & what a blast it mist have been to hear that happen live. Kudos and a +1
Black Throated Wind
Sept. 17, 1972
Baltimore Civic Center

stunningly confident, propulsive version. Weir's best pacing perhaps ever on this tune in both vocal delivery & rhythm. As others have noted Garcia digs deep & Keith adds all the most delicate accents at just the right moments. Exemplary.
Crazy Fingers
May 26, 1993
Cal Expo

Instrumentally nice version but typical for the year croaky-weak vocals from Jerry keep me from giving this an upvote. Lots of better versions currently sit under this one.
show more comments
headyversion loves the dead but is in no way affiliated with The Grateful Dead or affiliated enterprises. find out more >:) >:)