headyversion

find the best versions of grateful dead songs

please login or register.

grendel

Books and Music

+24543


Submissions

41
Sugar Magnolia
Oct. 29, 1977
Evans Field House, Northern Illinois University

Best ever. No fooling. Don't miss Mickey and Billy dueling each other at the frenzied end jam before heading into SSDD. Whole version insane!
80
Jack Straw
Oct. 20, 1984
Carrier Dome, Syracuse U

Crazy hard driving insanisty to end the first set. One of those jam segments that builds and builds and KABOOMS into final verse. Phil fans: a must
15
Stella Blue
April 19, 1982
Baltimore Civic Center

Sweet & melty....gorgeous harmonies from Brent.
88
Sugaree
Oct. 16, 1977
Louisiana State U

1977 was a helluva year for this song. I have no quarrel w/ 5/5, 5/19, or 5/21, but I think this one beats 'em all by a nose!
53
St. Stephen
Oct. 29, 1977
Evans Field House, Northern Illinois University

With all due rfespect to Barton Hall & others, this is the best version out there (IMO). Bluesy, rockin', jammin', just exactly perfect

Comments

Ship of Fools
Dec. 5, 1979
Uptown Theater

More than very nice. This underrated SOF contains a quadruple shot of Jerry in the instrumental break section, and it's phenomenal....spectral, piercing, crying notes into several bridges before landing dew-drop perfect into the reprise chorus. Much longer than almost any other version. 5/9/77 cannot be topped but this is easily THE best Brent-era version ever performed and may be #2 all-time.
The Other One
July 25, 1972
Paramount Theater

Nice St. Stephen teasing within the odd jam section as well. Most '72 versions of this song are a little too "out there" for my taste i.e. lots of feedback/noodling/weirdness for the sake of...) but this one's got more thoughtfulness to it. There's a good CM upgrade currently circulating on the archive...worth seeking out.
Not Fade Away
June 4, 1977
The Forum

True, true, true. This version suffers from one thing and one thing only: Lack of a damn SBD. Every time I hear this show I put it on mental wish list of shows that somehow turn up somewhere w/a long lost SBD so we can hear it as it was meant to be heard. Bloody shame, but no fault of the performance itself. If you can listen thru the AUD limitations you'll see how good it is. Plus the set list may be the most eclectic and interesting of the entire year, which only makes it that much more cruel that no SBD exists.
Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
Oct. 1, 1994
Boston Garden

Some of the nicest jamming of the year, but much as I'd like to for sentimental reasons, I can't give this one an upvote. Vocals are just too weak, and the jams, while nice for '94 like I said, just can't bear up i comparison to so many other years and versions on this site. it would cheapen the upvote process to give it a bump. But that said, it's a version that bears listening to (and obviously others will disagree and find it worthy), if only b/c by this year it was really hard to find any show that wasn't on some level sad for Jerry's overall decline. This Scarlet>Fire is mostly an exception to that and sweet in its way for at least hinting at the more beautiful years.
Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 17, 1977
Memorial Coliseum

Agree with Corals. This one is so good it absolutely deserves an upvote, but 5/21/77 remains the gold standard for 1977...this one might be right on its heels, which says a lot.