headyversion

find the best versions of grateful dead songs

please login or register.

grendel

Books and Music

+24533


Submissions

43
Estimated Prophet
April 19, 1982
Baltimore Civic Center

From the famous "ravenspace" show; the only version in which the main theme is reprised+lots of Bob yelling
64
Ship of Fools
May 9, 1977
War Memorial

Perfection. The "comes a time" for this show gets all the attention but this SOF is just as grand
64
Uncle John's Band
Oct. 12, 1984
Augusta Civic Center

Part of a 2nd set for the ages; flows in & out of PITB teases & then reprises into killer Dew
20
Terrapin Station
Dec. 31, 1987
Oakland Coliseum Arena

Hold on tight!
51
Bertha
Oct. 29, 1977
Evans Field House, Northern Illinois University

Sweet bass drop-ins by Phil on intro; extended Garcia solos in bridge jam; very intense and fun

Comments

Lazy Lightnin' -> Supplication
May 22, 1982
Greek Theatre - University of California

Nice pick...very good backing vocals on this one thanks to Brent and Garcia's way into it also. 5/22/77 is still my favorite and some of the other '77 jam sections are hard to beat but this one is maybe the best Brent-era I've heard.
Shakedown Street
Dec. 30, 1983
Civic Auditorium

DOES need to shoot up the list! This is a version where the post-lyrics jam has every bit as much inventiveness and crisp jazz improvising as the beginning portions do. Check out Jerry's lines around the 10 minute mark and his play-offs with Brent throughout. Bobby adds interesting counter-rhythms too and Phil is doing his rattle-your-bones bass thing. Really strong version that oughta be higher on the board.
Friend of the Devil
Oct. 29, 1977
Evans Field House, Northern Illinois University

A winner for sure. Can't find a clunker anywhere in this show.
Dark Star
Aug. 16, 1969
Yasgur's Farm

Almost getting fried by a lightning strike is a pretty good excuse!
Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 8, 1977
Barton Hall - Cornell University

It's not that this isn't a good version...it is. Maybe you could make the argument it's even "great", and in a top 10-20 discussion. What mystifies me about this version (and I'm not alone judging by just a few of the comments here) is that it's so often taken for granted as the best of the best. And that's just mind-bogglingly not true. 97 votes at this counting. That's about 65 too many by my estimation unless people are just adding their votes for it being great and not necessarily #1, which is fine...but then you should seek out equally worthy or better versions and vote those as well. If you feel like an objective experiment, take just these versions from the SAME MONTH--i'm not even getting into the apples & oranges of Brent v. Keith eras here, and compare them back to back w/this version, and see if you would change your vote: 5/13/77, 5/17/77, 5/21/77, 5/25/77. If you really believe any or all of those are not superior to 5/8, and thus should be ranked higher on this list, then I give up trying to convince otherwise.