The Other One
Sept. 17, 1972
Baltimore Civic Center
I share an enthusiasm for this song and the period as well, although I’ve never placed that much importance on this particular version, especially when considering its length. Make no mistake -- I think it’s a good one (and the show as a whole is very good) -- but like the Dark Star of 5/11/72 or the Playin’ of 5/21/74, its “beast status” is surely marked in part by its length alone. This version is a magnum opus! But does the end justify the means? Does the payoff justify the investment of time? I should say so -- but with reservation -- especially when considering the siblings of the era that I think are more entrancing and exhilarating in far fewer minutes (9/3, 9/9, 9/15, 9/28, 10/19, 10/24, 11/17 come to mind). But that hardly matters, of course, if one loves this version, and has 40 minutes to lend an ear! I’m just saying there are better versions that offer higher dividends for lower investments (read: 9/28 & 11/17). But this is only one head’s opinion, and I love the fact we all can come on here and discuss – with passion – the merits of Grateful Dead music at large. With that, I’m going to brew another cup, and spin a long Other One (how about 11/17/72?) I’ve got forty minutes to spare, and a smile to go with it!