Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 8, 1977
Barton Hall - Cornell University
It is likely that your reading of this song says more about you as a reader of the grateful dead than it does about this version of scarlet>fire as one of the grateful dead’s texts. This version of scarlet>fire is good – just how good it is at issue. And I say “song” and not “songs.” The marriage of these two was new, there was a minimum of deviation [254 times together, 38 times apart] in the eighteen years that followed and this was the first excellent version of scarlet>fire ("the song") for which a clear soundboard recording was widely available. That tape spread so widely that this show is now the only one of the dead’s archived at the Library of Congress. But let’s turn back to you, the “reader,” and scarlet>fire, the “text.” At some point we all discovered "the song" and became aware of the reputation of Cornell, either because Cornell was our introduction to "the song," or because we came to understand the importance of "the song" in the oeuvre and then sought out Cornell as a result. Would anyone care to say that "the song" is not an important part of being a deadhead? Does anyone not like "the song?" I am sure there are a few outliers who cannot stand to hear "the song." But what’s more likely is that as a reader, you became aware of "the song" and then it became an important part of the identity you constructed as a reader of the dead. Some construct their identity in opposition to this version - May 8, 1977 - of "the song," while others embrace Cornell to varying degrees of rapture. But scarlet>fire is as foundational a deadtext as dark star, eyes of the world or playin' in the band. The construction of an identity as a reader of the dead is, necessarily, important to all of the people who post on this website. Everyone here is actively cultivating a unique identity as a reader of the grateful dead. What makes this website compelling is that each of the dead’s songs can be a playground in which you construct your identity as a reader and furthermore, within each song, the separate versions allow each of us to further tweak and fine tune that identity. Is this the best scarlet>fire? Perhaps. Perhaps not. Is it the best grateful dead song? I pass. But if someone asked me where to start with scarlet>fire, I’d tell her to start here, and then I’d let her construct her own identity.